ANALYSIS | Why calling an early election would benefit Doug Ford | CBC News (2024)

If Premier Doug Ford decides to callan early election, political strategists say he'll need to giveOntario voters a compelling reason for why he's sending them to the polls ahead of schedule.

Over the past week, Ford has repeatedly declined to rule out calling an election before his government's four-year mandate expires in June 2026. Multiple sources close to the Progressive Conservatives say no decision has been made to proceed with a snap vote, but say late next spring is the most likely date.Ford told Ottawa radio station 580 CFRA on Wednesday that there will not be an election this summer or fall, but left open the possibility of a vote next year.

Strategists say there would be big political advantages for the Ontario PC Party to campaign before October 2025, when a federal election is widely expected. Chief among them: the presence of a Liberal government in Ottawa, particularly if it isstill led by Justin Trudeau.

Ford could benefit from Trudeau's current unpopularityand target the prime minister in much the same way that Trudeau targeted Ford in the 2019 federal campaign, when the then-rookie premier was low in the polls.

But is political advantage on its own enough justification for Ford to call the vote well before his mandate is up?Fred DeLorey, a veteran Conservative strategist at both the federal and provincial levels, says no.

"If they're calling it [early]simply because the polls are good for them, then that's a strategic mistake," said DeLorey, who was director of operations for the Ontario PC 2018 campaign that brought Ford to power, and is now a partner with Northstar Public Affairs.

WATCH| Talk of an early election rampsup at Queen's Park:

"They have to tell a story that we need this election for a reason," said DeLorey"If you have a narrative that you're running on, and you could go to Ontarians and say, 'We need a new mandate because we want to get X, Y and Z done,' then I think the cynicism would disappear."

'Inviting people to punish you'

David Herle, a longtime federal and provincial Liberal strategist, has a similar perspective. He says the biggest risk for Ford of calling a vote early is voters perceiving the move as cynical and self-serving.

"If it's cloaked purely in politics, you're inviting people to punish you for it," said Herle, who ran Kathleen Wynne'sprovincial election campaigns in 2014 and 2018.

Herle recently joined Rubicon Strategy, a lobbying firm led by Kory Teneycke, who led Ford's Ontario PC campaigns in 2018 and 2022.

He says one reasonwhy Trudeau's Liberals failed to win a majority in 2021 is because the party didn't give voters a compelling reason why the election had to be called at that time, during the pandemic, just two years after the previous election.

"When [an early election] works, generally it's because the government has ginned up an issue that justifies that call," Herle said.

Ontario's fixed-date election law sets voting day as four years into a government's mandate, but the law also explicitly allows the premier to dissolvethe legislature and call an election at any time before then.

While Herle and DeLorey both believe Ford will need to justify an early election, they also firmly believe the move would be to his benefit.

"If it's advantageous to your party to call an early election, you should do it," said DeLorey. "Just looking at the political side, if I was in any province as a premier, as a Conservative, I would want to make sure my election is while Justin Trudeau is still prime minister.He is historically unpopular."

Herle's take is that when Trudeau is no longer in power, voterswill be looking for someone else to blame for political and economic problems.

"Housing will still be expensive, health care will still be difficult to access, groceries will still be costly," he said.

"Right now, I think almost all the premiers are getting a pretty free ride on this because Trudeau gets blamed for everything.But when he's gone, people are going to start looking at [premiers] and saying, 'Well, what are you doing?'"

Another factor at play is the overwhelming evidence of more than 60 years of Ontario's political history.

Since 1963, the party that won power in all but one of the last 17 Ontario electionswas different from the party in power federally at the time. (The sole exception: Dalton McGuinty's Ontario Liberal victory in 2003, when Liberal Jean Chretien was prime minister.)

'Voters won't care' about early call

Laryssa Waler, who served as Ford's director of communications until 2020 and is now with the lobbying firm GT and Company,says that historical trend alone should be enough to persuade the premier to call the election before a federal vote happens.

"I would hope he would make that decision," Waler said in an interview. "It's the smart thing to do."

She is not convinced that Ford needs togive voters much justification for a snap call.

"If he calls an election early, I don't think that voters would penalize him for that,I don't think a single vote would change," she said."Voters aren't really going to care. There's no incremental cost to having an election sooner than you would have had otherwise."

Waler says Ford simply has to show voters that he needs a new mandate because his government has achieved much of what the PCs promised to do in the last election.

Thatcould be a bit of a tough sell for Ford, given that housing starts are nowhere near on pace for his target for 1.5 million homes, construction has yet to begin on Highway 413and many of the new hospital projects he announced in the last campaign remain in the planning stages.

Nevertheless, Ford might vastly prefer a sooner-rather-than-later election for another reason: it would mean less time for the RCMPto complete its Greenbelt investigation and lay charges if warranted.

Early election speculation ramped up at Queen's Park over the past week since Ford announced plans to allow convenience stores to sell beer, wine and ready-to-drink co*cktails come September, 16 months ahead of schedule.

The move will cost taxpayers at least $225 millionin apayment to the Beer Storefor early termination ofa contract that was set to expire at the end of December 2025. Industry sources say the changes will also see the government lose out on LCBO revenues that could run into the hundreds of millions of dollars annually.

WATCH | Adding up the cost of Doug Ford's changes to alcohol retailing:

Kevin Gaudet, another veteran Conservative strategist and founder of lobby firmBrightPoint Strategy, says the political risks for Ford of calling an early election are greater than the risks of waiting until 2026.

"If one goes to an election extra early, opponents and media could easily call it a cynical ploy," Gaudet said in an interview.

'His opponents are discombobulated'

Gaudet thinks there may be some strategic gamesmanship at play in talk of an early election, asit helps the PCs keepthe opposition parties off balance.

"Why should the premier guarantee the exact future election date when he doesn't need to, when the benefit of not doing so is that his opponents are discombobulated and made to feel uncertain?" he said.

Ford's PCs hold a dramatic resource advantage over the opposition parties, having raised millions of dollars more since the 2022 election.

The PCs have spent some of that haul in recent months on high-profile advertising, including TV attack ads targeting Liberal leader Bonnie Crombie and a campaign showing Ford talking on the phone and saying he's "listening and working hard to make things better for every single person in Ontario."

The last time an Ontario premier with a majority called an election well before the traditional four-year mark, it certainly backfired. In 1990, then-premierDavid Peterson sent voters to the polls three years into his mandate, but his Liberals lost, giving Bob Rae's NDP its first and still only Ontario election victory.